Portugal saw the USA’s attitude and found it good. But Portugal couldn’t just do the same, for it doesn’t know much about the internetz. And thus, in order to get a tiny wee bit of SOPA-like awesomeness, it decided to create the #PL118.
#PL118 is the name of a bill they’re trying to get passed around here. It’s quite the funny bill and will make lots of people happy. It is only the natural follower of the law we already have had around here for the past 14 years, which stated that a small fee should be payed everytime you buy something where you can allocate data. But the PL is pretty much like an upgrade on the older law/bill. Instead of paying a fixed fee, they’re trying to make the consumer pay around €0,02 for each GB they buy. It is said that this money will eventually help the authors of IP content. And while proteting IP content (I’m not talking about the IP act!) is sort of a good thing, the bill has this funny smell about it…
I’ll tell you why my nose isn’t happy about this.
First things first: it’s a tax we’ll be paying a priori. This means we’ll be paying a fee as a pushiment for a crime we can potencially commit by the usage of saying storage devices. We’ll pay the fee even if we don’t store IP protected material on our disks. It’s like paying child support for a child you never had, if you ask me. This bill just assumes everyone is a pottencial criminal and everyone should pay in advance.
Second: despite the first point, we can still ask how is this money helping authors. Well, it won’t. Not for the most part. Authors are not the direct benefeciaries of this money; they only get a really small share. Where does the rest of the money go? Producers and representative entities. Well, I guess this falls into the SOPA-like awkward thing. I know the consequences aren’t as hard as on the SOPA case, but the cause seems pretty similar: corporations trying not to lose their money due to the internet or file sharing. What these frightened corporations need to get into their “heads” by now is that with the internet, a whole new marketing model arises. There’s no middle man on the internet. You can buy your art/music/files directly from the author. And store them in your disks! What’s the sense of a tax that’s supposed to help authors when I have already payed them for the material? And they don’t get a small share of the money, they get 100% of the money! There’s a different way of thinking here. No middlemen. And now the middlemen are afraid to lose their power and try to make us pay a nonsensical fee.
If they’re trying to get us rid of piracy (aka trying to protect IP), it’s not by adding constrains that the problem will be solved. Piracy is not about content, it’s about service. An extra tax won’t do much for stopping piracy, it will only do worse for those who don’t act pirate-ish. The problem can only be solved by providing better consumer-services, which many authors are already doing by confronting their buyers directly instead of getting middlemen in the story.